Cittanuova

AAA Diamond Inspector Notes

Tucked along the village’s main street, this intimate Italian restaurant offers a contemporary yet welcoming dining experience that feels perfectly in step with the relaxed elegance of the Hamptons. The menu focuses on traditional Tuscan-inspired cuisine, with house-made pastas, simply prepared seafood, and expertly grilled meats that highlight fresh, high-quality ingredients. The dining room is warm and understated, with soft lighting, rustic wood accents, and closely set tables that create a lively, convivial atmosphere without feeling crowded, while a charming outdoor patio provides a quieter setting for dining in warmer weather. Service is polished and attentive, striking the right balance between professional and genuinely friendly, with staff who are confident in guiding guests through the menu and wine list.